Biotech CEO Hypes His Research
Boy am I ticked! It turns out that Robert Lanza, the CEO of
Advanced Cell Technologies pretty much lied in the clip I played for you in the last episode. Here's what he said: "What we have done, for the first time, is to actually create human embryonic stem cells without destroying the embryo itself." Yeah, well, that's pretty much just a straight out lie.
Very quickly it became apparent that the company had destroyed the embryos during the experiment. The good news was that as a registered member of the press, I received the correction from Nature Magazine almost immediately, and Nature also published an article on their website describing the discrepancy. Still, I was really surprised that Nature didn't mention it in their next podcast. Their podcast was my source for the audio clip, and given that the podcast is where Lanza made his bogus statement, I would have expected them to make a correction in the podcast.
Here's the bottom line. The paper itself appears to be accurate, showing that they took cells from blastocysts that were destroyed and used single cells to make stem cell lines. In theory, this implies that it should be possible to take single cells from blastocysts and make stem cell lines without destroying embryos, but they haven't actually proved that yet. They haven't done it. They've just shown that it should be able to be done. The problem is that in every communication other than the paper itself -- in the abstract, the press release, and the interviews that Lanza gave -- they misled the public.
It's a really stupid, annoying move on the part of the company that just contributes to the erosion of public trust in scientists, and casts a shadow of suspicion on all stem cell research that comes out in the future. So, way to go Robert Lanza and Advanced Cell Technologies, you've done a big disservice to your entire field.
Interview/Listener Question
John in Helendale asked, "How can researchers really know what the climate was like so far into the past?" With thanks to Bruce at ORNL, we hooked up with
Dr. Reid Bryson, a Senior Scientist, Center for Climatic Research at the University of Wisconsin, to answer that question.
NewsCervical Cancer VaccineRemember Merck's cervical cancer vaccine, Gardasil, was hailed as a major breakthrough? Supposedly doctors in the U.S. are waiting for insurance companies to start covering the vaccine before recommending it to patients. Way to put money ahead of health people.
Article (sub. req.) - Source Fierce Biotech
Stem CellsHere's another stem cell story. Honestly, I'm getting tired of stem cells. OK, the
BBC reported that British authorities have had to warn people against going to other countries, supposedly especially the Netherlands, where companies are making extravagant claims about miracle stem cell cures. They warned that the treatments for conditions like multiple sclerosis were dangerous and unproven. But here's what really gets me: The final quote in the article quotes a Professor Colin Blakemore, as saying that patients who seek these treatments are endangering the field of stem cell research because if they get cancer or something from the treatment, it could set the whole field back. Yeah Blakemore, it's the patients who believe the false promises who are going to hurt the field, not the scoundrels who make the claims in the first place. God, let's just hope he was quoted out of context, because if not that's really ridiculous.
Shout Outs & AdministrativeI apologize, I don't have any shout outs this week. My computer crashed and I lost the file where I had been saving everyone's names. But do know that we really appreciate it when you write in and I do still have any questions and topic ideas that you submitted because I keep those in a separate file.
Also, we're not podfading, but I just can't tell you what kind of schedule the show is going to be on for a while. It could be one a week or it could be once a month, it kind of depends on Adam's availability and our both of our work schedules. So thanks for sticking with us, while we get back on track.
Calendar ContestHere's a happier thing to end this disgruntled episode! We've gotten a couple of great submissions to the 2007 calendar contest, but we still need more. Remember to send your cool science pictures to absolutescience [at] welltopia.com, and the deadline is November 15. Also, I want to get the word out on this so we have the very best pictures to choose from. If there's an email list at your university that goes out to graduate students or postdocs, could you drop me and email and let me know who to contact to put an announcement on the list?
Also, Absolute Science got reviewed by a couple of different podcast reviewers, and they all seem to agree that we're great, but that well, I'm not terribly funny.
Podcast FanaticUpon Further ReviewThey encouraged me to keep trying, but for this week I'm going to combine our comedy section with our music section and leave you with a funny science song called Hooray for NRM Spectroscopy by
Science Groove. I've had this in my playlist for a long time and it has really grown on me.